The Age
October
31, 2013
Amrit
Dhillon
In
the endless fight against superstition and fakery in India, campaigners for
rationalism have to use every trick in the book to beat so-called holy men at
their own game.
Standing in front of the schoolchildren at
Desu Madra Secondary School in Mohali, in the Indian state of Punjab, Satnam
Singh Daun spreads his props out on the table: scarves and money that vanish,
cards, powders that burst into flames, some rope, matches, vials, cotton wool.
He looks like a magician about to start a show at a child's birthday party.
But
the tricks are not for entertaining the children. Daun is using them to expose
the godmen, gurus, astrologers, charlatans, soothsayers, palmists, charm
sellers, quacks, and humbugs who are so popular in India.
The
children, seated on the ground in the bright sunshine and humidity that follows
a monsoon downpour, listen intently to Daun as he pours scorn on superstition.
He performs the same tricks that are used by holy men to exploit the
gullibility of Indians and project themselves as possessing supernatural powers
- making money disappear or turning 100 rupee notes into 500 rupee notes,
producing ash from nowhere, swallowing fire.
''It's
because they are too stupid to become teachers, doctors or scientists that
godmen become astrologers to fool people,'' Daun says.
Advertisement
''They
want you to use amulets and trust in the stars instead of using your reason.
These holy men are holy fools tricking you. Be rational, use your minds,'' says
Daun, as a rooster in the school grounds crows on cue as if to say ''hear
hear''.
Daun
is one of three men in Mohali known as ''gurubusters''. He is talking to the
schoolchildren, accompanied by his two colleagues, to teach them to spurn
superstition and be rational instead.
Daun is short and stocky and works as an
Amway agent. His co-gurubuster Harpreet Rora is a slight, fresh-faced young man
who works as a journalist. The third is the founder of the Mohali branch of the
Indian Rationalist Association, the burly and avuncular Jarnail Singh Kranti, a
retired primary school teacher. From a tiny office, using their own funds and
their spare time, the endearing threesome, loyally supported by their wives,
launch blistering broadsides against India's influential godmen. This is the
headquarters of a lonely mission: promoting the supremacy of rationalism.
Superstition
is a multimillion-dollar industry in India. From the poorest to the richest,
the predisposition to superstition is embedded in the neural pathway of most
Indians. Choosing a spouse, fixing a wedding date, getting a job, trying for a
baby boy, curing an alcoholic husband, reviving a failing business, curing an
illness, ending a factory strike - all these problems require a visit to a holy
man, who is paid a fortune for his services.
The
propensity to believe that some mystic will solve your problems runs across the
social spectrum. Former prime ministers have consulted bead-wearing astrologers
on the most ''auspicious''' date for a general election. Bollywood stars offer
tributes at the shrines of mystics to ensure a box office hit.
Given
their preference for discretion, wealthy Indians prefer to have a guru dedicated
to their family; sometimes he lives with them so that he can be available at
all times.
''I
have total faith in my guru. He can cure cancer. I have seen it. I come away
after an audience with him feeling light and blessed,'' says New Delhi garment
exporter Rocky Verma, who has just asked his guru to suggest a date for his
son's engagement.
Talk
to the wives of tycoons and it becomes clear their faith in their family guru
is blind. New Delhi art collector and gallery owner Renu Modi is married into
the famous Modi business family and she is totally dependent on her guru, Swami
Chandra. ''We do not make any major decision without first consulting him,''
she says.
On
Delhi's Prithviraj Road, home to many business moguls, Madhushree Birla, the
wife of a scion of the Birla dynasty, sits in a living room full of priceless
artefacts and talks of how she relies on Patrick, a Christian faith healer from
Goa who she says can cure cancer.
''My
faith in him stems from the day my brother and sister-in law were involved in a
horrific car crash near Nasik. My brother had broken ribs and my sister-in-law
suffered serious internal bleeding.
''Two
minutes after they crashed, they were still lying there stunned but just
beginning to realise what had happened when Patrick called them on the phone.
He had seen everything that had happened and he knew what injuries they had
suffered even though he was far away in Goa,'' she says.
This
is the kind of belief that Daun likes to pour his vitriol on. As the morning
sun rises higher in the sky, he ignores the heat and starts getting into his
stride, asking the schoolchildren, ''Has any holy man ever invented a medicine
or an airplane? Can he stop any of you dying in a road accident? How can he
help you do well in exams and get a good job when he himself is nothing but a
failure?''
Standing
behind Daun is his wife Neeraj. She hands him something. Daun pops a burning
ball of fire into his mouth, eliciting gasps from the schoolchildren. Then he
shows them that it is only burning camphor, which cannot hurt his mouth. He
dips his hand into burning oil, unscathed, showing them later that he had
pre-soaked his hand in oil as insulation.
At the
end of the talk, the children troop out to join their classes, having promised
Daun that they will never again succumb to superstition. When they have
finished handing out leaflets, the energetic gurubusting triumvirate pack their
props, mount their scooters and head off to another assignment at another
school to educate children on the importance of being rational.
The
Indian Rationalist Association was founded in 1949, with the good wishes of British
philosopher Bertrand Russell. Its first members belonged to the educated elite.
It has rarely had more than 100,000 members - mainly teachers, students and
professionals - but they have been vigorous in publishing pamphlets and
deriding the Indian penchant for superstitious nonsense.
Over
the decades, its branches have tried to inculcate Indians with a scientific
temperament through debate, talks, ridicule, humour and challenges. Much of
their time is spent performing the tricks that self-styled holy men love to
perform to convince Indians of their special powers and to garner billions of
rupees from their credulity.
''Their
press conferences are hilarious because they consume fire, levitate (a trick
requiring a blanket and two hockey sticks), walk on coals (the skin doesn't
burn if you walk fast enough) and make statues 'weep' (melting a layer of wax
covering a small deposit of water),'' says Mumbai journalist Neeraj Gaitonde.
''It's the only way to destroy the blind belief in their special powers.''
Some
charlatans are more creative than others. One used to impress the crowds by
''creating'' fire by pouring ghee (clarified butter) onto ash and then
''staring'' at it until the mixture burst into flames.
Rationalists-turned-detectives found that the ghee was glycerine and the ash
was potassium permanganate and the two spontaneously combust a couple of
minutes after they are combined.
India's
rationalists love to challenge quacks. When the well-known television guru
Pandit Surinder Sharma boasted on television in 2008 that he could kill another
man using only his mystical powers, Sanal Edamaruku, president of the Indian
Rationalist Association (who is currently in hiding in Finland, but more of
that later) took up the challenge and invited the guru to kill him on
prime-time television.
The
guru agreed and appeared on television performing sundry rituals intended to
kill Edamaruku. Millions tuned to the show. The hocus pocus went on for some
time. The holy man ruffled the rationalist's hair, pressed his temples and
mumbled incantations. Several hours later, Edamaruku was still alive,
cheerfully taunting the frustrated killer.
Edamaruku,
a former journalist, became a rationalist activist when he was 15 after seeing
a local athlete with blood cancer die because her family refused medical
treatment, preferring a faith healer. Now he lives in Finland, having fled
India after the Catholic Church in Mumbai filed a complaint against him in
April 2012 under the country's blasphemy law. If convicted he would face three
years in jail.
The
case concerned a crucifix dripping water at a Mumbai church. Edamaruku
discovered the dripping was caused by a leaky cistern that was causing water to
seep through the wall onto the crucifix. He reported his results on television
and criticised the Catholic Church for being ''anti-science''. When the church
filed a case against him, he fled.
Not so
lucky was Dr Narendra Dabholkar, a prominent anti-black magic campaigner in
Pune, near Mumbai, who was murdered on August 20. Known for his lifelong
campaign against superstition, Dabholkar, 70, was gunned down during his
morning walk.
Dabholkar
estimated that several hundred women are killed every year after being branded
''witches'' by so-called godmen. He also pointed out many children also were
killed as part of ''human sacrifices'' ordered by godmen to resolve their
followers' problems.
Indians
were shocked at the murder; some were equally surprised to discover that
Dabholkar had been lobbying the provincial government of Maharashtra to approve
the Superstition Eradication and Anti-Black Magic Bill to make superstitious
practices illegal.
Despite
receiving several death threats from right-wing Hindu groups, Dabholkar refused
police protection. These groups believed he was targeting their religion and
not condemning superstition in all religions.
However,
the evidence suggests Hindu charlatans predominate (Hinduism in the largest
religion in India), partly because there is no organised structure to the
religion nor an established hierarchy, making it easy for anyone to set himself
up as a guru offering spiritual advice.
Invariably,
the majority of the controversial godmen who end up in the news for amassing
millions, owning fleets of Mercedes and Audis, for being involved in
prostitution rackets or are charged with sexual abuse or rape, are Hindu.
Just
last month, a leading godman called Asaram Bapu was arrested on charges of
sexually assaulting a 15-year-old. Yet, seeing their godman behind bars has
done little to dent the faith of his supporters.
''These
godmen are like Jekyll and Hyde. They do a lot of social and community work
initially to become popular before they start gratifying themselves,'' says Dr
Indira Sharma, president of the Indian Psychiatric Society.
''They
help with marriages, school admissions, medical treatment. So when they are
charged with an offence, their supporters are not affected because they want to
continue getting that help and it's in their interest to protect the godman.''
The
Mohali gurubusters, always cheerful and energetic, have so far not received any
threats.
''We
won't stop, particularly when it comes to educating children,'' says Harpreet
Rora. ''We want children to become ambassadors of change. They have to go home
and tell their parents to stop their nonsense.''
The
cost of superstition in India is high. All over the country, hanging in shops,
homes, workshops and vehicles, are small bunches of green chillies and lemons
tied together to ward off the evil eye and bring good luck. Fresh bunches are
hung every day.
''Do
you know that Indians spend 104 million rupees ($2.4 million) every year on
buying chillies and lemons?'' says Jarnail Singh Kranti.
''At
our local hospital, they have an astrologer on hand to 'help' patients if the
medical treatment fails. This must stop. We must start relying on science and
logic to move into the modern world.''
It is
in the interests of Indian politicians, he adds, to keep Indians mired in
superstition so that the poor don't start asking, ''Why are we poor?''
Before
closing the shutters on the office, he points to a large poster hanging on the
wall. It offers a reward of 2.3 million rupees ($39,000) to any godman who can
perform any one of 23 acts, including standing on burning cinders for half a
minute without blistering his feet; reading the thoughts of another person;
making an amputated limb grow even one inch through prayer, spiritual powers,
using holy ash, or giving blessings; walking on water; getting out of a locked
room by divine power; or converting water into petrol.
As he
reads out the list, Kranti chuckles. ''We don't have 2.3 million rupees. But
we're not expecting anyone to win so we're pretty safe,'' he says.
Amrit Dhillon is a Delhi-based
writer.
